How can showing vulnerability enhance your leadership?
Traditionally, the image of a leader has centered around a strong, unwavering figure, leading their team from the front, trailblazing the way through uncharted territory to guide and instruct their followers through challenges towards a target destination. More recently, other analogies paint a slightly different picture of leadership including but not limited to: leading from the back like a shepherd guiding the flock; the bridge builder – who connects people, ideas and opportunities; the firefighter – a crisis orientated leader, thriving under pressure and solving problems; and the chess master – a strategic leader planning ahead.
Evidently the landscape of effective leadership is dynamic and evolving. In today's interconnected world, there's a growing acknowledgment that vulnerability can be a potent tool for effective leadership, especially in educational settings.
Redefining Leadership: The Strength in Vulnerability
It is becoming more and more widely accepted that leadership is about connection, empathy, and trust. Embracing vulnerability in leadership offers a paradigm shift from the traditional top-down model towards a more inclusive and relatable approach.
When educational leaders demonstrate vulnerability, they create a culture of openness and authenticity within their institutions. They set the stage for open dialogue, where teachers, students, and staff feel comfortable expressing their concerns, ideas, and uncertainties within a psychologically safe culture. However as you may have guessed (and experienced first hand), it is not easy to strike the balance; being too vulnerable with staff can create a different host of challenges, including creating an emotional burden on the team, loss of authority, low team morale, perceived weakness and blurred boundaries to name but a few.
Building Trust and Connection
Vulnerability breeds trust. When a leader shows vulnerability, it humanises them, making them more relatable to their team but also creates a culture where others feel safe to be vulnerable which can lead to a wide range of growth, development and innovation possibilities for individuals, communities and organisations. In educational settings, this is crucial. Students and staff are more likely to trust a leader who acknowledges their own limitations, uncertainties, and mistakes and with such shows value and appreciation for the contributions of others. But the balance must be there:
Boundaries must be in place, where leaders remain aware of what they are sharing, with whom and when
The lens must be shifted: whilst sharing vulnerabilities, leaders are aware of the lens they are using and are able to shift this as appropriate for example, to a solution focused and constructive lens according to the lens of those they are engaging with.
If sharing vulnerabilities are not fostering connection and growth then it begs the question – is it the right environment or the right tone?
Educational institutions are hotbeds of innovation and growth. However, as we have discussed in our previous blogs, often there can be an embedded culture of fear of failure or where people feel they cannot show what they consider to be a weakness. This not only stifles creativity but can lead to a stagnant working environment with a strengthening resistance to change.
By admitting when they don't have all the answers and being open to learning from failures, leaders inspire their teams to approach challenges with courage and resilience. This mindset shift fuels innovation through having an open space to authentically challenge and fosters an environment where both personal and institutional growth are given the permission to flourish. This can create a healthy and innovative cultural cadence and a deliberately developmental organisation as it becomes easier to raise and uses mistakes as learning opportunities, encouraging calculated risks to develop their structures, practices and processes.
Empathy and Understanding
Educational leaders who exhibit vulnerability also generally also find themselves in a better position to empathise with their team members due to an improved understanding of the struggles and uncertainties faced by others. This comes from deeper insight into others. With empathy, leaders seek perspectives from their team and as a result incorporate diverse viewpoints into their decision-making processes. This skill however requires in-the-moment awareness, which in times of vulnerability can be easily missed.
As we have highlighted, the main way to show vulnerability as a leader is to lead by example and share your experiences with your team. We’re not talking about your deepest and darkest secrets or personal experiences that have impacted you as the appropriateness of sharing these will depend on your audience and your context; whilst it is healthy to embrace vulnerability, it is important to stay professional. We're talking about sharing your own stories and challenges of growth in relevant settings, reaching out to appropriate team members who can offer insights and their own specialist skills and knowledge for areas they may be more experienced in; collaboration and discussions with others within your community regarding big decisions; sharing your processes and learning with others.
This is where our diagnostics into understanding leaders’ own lenses and that of their team provide a professional dialogue over a shared model of values and beliefs. This insight provides the tools to understand where drivers have emerged from and how they can be maximised.
Challenges and Considerations
While the benefits of embracing vulnerability in educational leadership are significant, it's essential to acknowledge the challenges. In environments where strength and unwavering confidence have long been the norm, shifting to vulnerability can be met with resistance or skepticism.
Additionally, there's a fine line between being vulnerable and oversharing. Leaders must strike a balance, being open about their struggles without undermining their authority or making others uncomfortable.
Educational leaders who dare to be vulnerable pave the way for a new era of leadership—one that prioritises authenticity, connection, and the collective growth of the entire educational community. In this journey, it's not about being flawless; it's about being real, and that's what truly inspires others to follow. To ensure this is applied effectively, check in with yourself as to how self-aware you are of your values and beliefs – if you are unsure, connect with a coach who can shine some light on your own journey to this point and how you can maximise your own and teams potential for transformation.
As educational leaders, embracing vulnerability might just be the catalyst for transformative change within our organisations.
If you are interested in exploring cutting edge coaching or team opportunities further for either yourself or your team and the benefits it can offer more widely for your organisation, we would be delighted to discuss options further. Please book an introductory call or contact us at info@glasshouselab.com.
You can also sign up to our newsletter to stay in touch.