School Leadership: Where Do We Go Now?
School leadership has long been the cornerstone of education systems worldwide, guiding institutions through shifts in pedagogy, societal changes, and technological advancements. Traditionally, leadership in schools often mirrored hierarchical structures, where a Headteacher held the reins of decision-making, setting the tone for the entire institution. This is likely what most of us experienced as we moved through statutory education. However, the landscape of education has been evolving rapidly, prompting a reevaluation of these conventional leadership models and asking the question; how do leaders evolve if they are to lead system change?
For decades, the prevailing style of school leadership adhered to a top-down approach. Headteachers held significant authority, often making crucial decisions without substantial input from teachers, students, or the wider stakeholders. They were seen as the ultimate authority figure whose decision making was final and the expectations that staff and students alike responded accordingly. This autocratic style, while sometimes effective in maintaining order, occasionally stifled innovation and hindered collaboration among stakeholders within the school environment.
This bureaucratic framework that in many cases, continues to characterise educational institutions, even as schools have scaled to MATS. This largely limits the adaptability necessary for addressing the diverse needs of students and navigating the complexities of modern society. The emphasis on hierarchy has sometimes resulted in a lack of empowerment among teachers, stifling their potential to contribute innovative ideas or initiatives that could benefit the learning environment. Whilst very often this creates a standardised system, an important part of organisational maturity, where initiatives are implemented organisation wide by teachers to achieve consistency and predictability, this is where it usually stops. In being prescriptive the design system is distanced from those expected to adopt it and the feedback loop is never closed leading to a lack of effective change management and an emerging sophistication of the system. This creates a lack of flexibility that is then reinforced by quality assurance visits and systems that appears to be abrasive when ‘checking’ that things are being done the way we told you to. More often this breeds a lack of psychological safety and a risk aversion that is required for innovation within the school (see our previous blog on nurturing psychological safety).
This being said, the educational landscape is shifting, and the trajectory of school leadership is evolving to embrace more inclusive and collaborative approaches that can lead to human, community, and system transformation. The collaborative nature of our community is the vehicle for changing the system, but this requires a leader to be a developmental point themselves that they can understand the perspective of others and then nuance the change process, nurturing a community of growth rather than getting in the way.
Embracing a Collaborative Paradigm
Contemporary educational research and progressive pedagogical movements advocate for a more participatory and collaborative style of leadership. Schools are recognizing the importance of distributed leadership, acknowledging that effective leadership can emerge from various levels and roles within an institution.
This shift toward distributed leadership involves sharing responsibilities and decision-making among teachers, administrators, students, parents, and the broader community. By fostering a culture of collective responsibility, schools can harness the diverse expertise and perspectives of stakeholders, thereby enhancing the overall learning experience.
Through our work with a number of educational leadership teams across the UK we have found that as the leadership team understands the lines of human development and compare the stages each other are at on the journey, the clearer the distinction becomes that we hold our own unique lens on every decision we make or opinion we take. This sounds obvious in a practical sense but bringing it to our attention continuously is like going to the gym, we have to repeat it it we are to use it. This is where vertical development comes in. We are not simply adding more knowledge, skills or behaviours, but upgrading the quality of our insight, data, and therefore decision making, conscious of the fact that we must consult the unique lens of the stakeholder we are engaging with if we are to understand what is behind how they are showing up and how to facilitate them moving forward. With every team we have worked with over the last year it has unlocked the potential of the staff team because they are able to create agency for others to share their journey and integrate where they want to go into their strategy, tapping into new reserves of talent and energy that they were simply not aware of before.
The Role of Technology in Redefining Leadership
To accelerate the potential of this transformation, we see the use of technology as essential in augmenting this revolutionised education, not so that it dictates change to us but provides a platform for a network of conscious change agents with a space to connect. Our digital tools and platforms have reshaped the way leaders, teachers, and students learn and interact with information about each other and their systems. Our leaders have begun to navigate this technological terrain, integrating it into the educational framework but also their culture design leading to leaps in productivity, insight and reinforcement of clarity and connection that is essential for trust and change.
Competent leadership within the digital world is essential for education, with the fast paced emergence and development of AI (artificial intelligence) across the globe, educational leaders need to be aware of how these tools can be accessed and used by both staff and students safely, rather than being hijacked for attention and intimacy. More often, schools are resistant to such changes which can lead to a wider gap between student competence in use, safely in use and deepen the digital divide across communities. Yet when given insight into themselves and shared frameworks for design and networking, their psychological needs are met and their motivation and engagement drives strategic thinking far beyond their previous experiences.
The Department for Education (2023) recently updated guidance on Generative artificial intelligence in education; whilst this is a useful introduction to the safe and responsible use of new AI tools, however it could be argued that there is (as with the national curriculum guidance more widely) an over-emphasis on the importance of knowledge. Whilst again we would agree that knowledge is a key part of education, it neglects the wider development of the person as a whole, what about their self-awareness - essential for understanding their emotions, regulation and how to interact with others?; what about their critical thinking that goes beyond knowledge and fact, and the key human aspects of empathy, compassion, perspective taking that a computer is not capable of? Knowledge can only get them so far and we would argue that school and digital leaders need to be aware how technology can be used safely to facilitate the development of staff and students across these areas of social and emotional development that make them distinguishable from AI and standard exam results.
On a more practical level, technology also enables leaders to foster greater transparency and communication within the school community and truly model how the community is living its values and aligning to its purpose. Platforms for online collaboration, communication, and data analysis empower educators to make more informed decisions and engage in continuous improvement efforts that can be rapid and host live data to nuance their school’s offer now and in the longer term.
Cultivating a Culture of Innovation and Adaptability
In an ever-changing world, integration and innovation have become crucial skills. Effective school leaders understand the importance of cultivating environments that encourage experimentation and creativity. They empower their staff to take calculated risks, learn from failures, and continuously refine teaching practices to meet the evolving needs of students.
Encouraging a culture of innovation involves fostering professional development opportunities that allow educators to explore new teaching methodologies, leverage emerging technologies, and stay abreast of educational research. This approach equips teachers with the tools and knowledge needed to engage students effectively and prepare them for an increasingly dynamic future.
This approach requires a level of trust and autonomy for other staff members. School leaders require a psychologically safe environment, where staff are able to ask questions, be vulnerable and learn from each other and their mistakes. For this to happen, leaders need to lead by example by doing just that and this takes the courage and clarity to demonstrate vulnerability and often that they are human after all!
As we navigate the complexities of modern education, the path forward for school leadership lies in embracing innovation, collaboration, inclusivity, and adaptability. The traditional hierarchical model, while having its merits, no longer fully meets the diverse needs of students or the demands of a rapidly changing world.
The future of school leadership involves a dynamic and inclusive approach, where leaders facilitate collaboration, empower stakeholders, leverage technology responsibly, and prioritise student-centred learning not only in response to the changing world, but also in anticipation of it. By championing these principles, educators can steer schools toward becoming vibrant, adaptive learning communities that prepare students not only for academic success but also for lifelong learning and success in an ever-evolving global society. The status-quo is no longer sufficient if leaders, teachers, and students are to thrive in their adult lives and work effectively to address the wicked problems that are affective societies on a global scale.
If you are interested in exploring cutting edge coaching opportunities further for either yourself or your team and the benefits it can offer more widely for your organisation, we would be delighted to discuss options further. Please book a discovery call or contact us at info@glasshouselab.com.
You can also sign up to our newsletter to stay in touch.
References:
Department of Education (DfE). (2023). Generative artificial intelligence (AI) in education. [online]. Available from: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/generative-artificial-intelligence-in-education